3.6 KiB
3.6 KiB
Specification Quality Checklist: Google Drive HTTP Proxy Adapter
Purpose: Validate specification completeness and quality before proceeding to planning Created: 2026-03-06 Feature: spec.md
Content Quality
- No implementation details (languages, frameworks, APIs)
- Focused on user value and business needs
- Written for non-technical stakeholders
- All mandatory sections completed
Requirement Completeness
- No [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers remain
- Requirements are testable and unambiguous
- Success criteria are measurable
- Success criteria are technology-agnostic (no implementation details)
- All acceptance scenarios are defined
- Edge cases are identified
- Scope is clearly bounded
- Dependencies and assumptions identified
Feature Readiness
- All functional requirements have clear acceptance criteria
- User scenarios cover primary flows
- Feature meets measurable outcomes defined in Success Criteria
- No implementation details leak into specification
Validation Notes
Content Quality Review
- ✅ Specification avoids implementation details (no mention of specific npm packages, frameworks beyond Node.js requirement from constitution)
- ✅ Focus is on user capabilities (HTTP requests, document export, sitemap generation)
- ✅ Language is accessible to non-developers (clear descriptions of HTTP endpoints and document formats)
- ✅ All sections (User Scenarios, Requirements, Success Criteria, Assumptions, Out of Scope) are complete
Requirement Completeness Review
- ✅ No [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers present - all requirements are fully specified
- ✅ Requirements are testable:
- FR-001 through FR-020 can all be verified through automated tests
- Each functional requirement specifies a MUST condition that is verifiable
- ✅ Success criteria are measurable with specific metrics:
- SC-001: 5 seconds for 10,000 documents
- SC-002: 3 seconds for <1MB documents
- SC-003: 100 concurrent requests
- SC-004 through SC-010: All have quantifiable targets
- ✅ Success criteria avoid implementation details (focus on timing, throughput, quality metrics)
- ✅ Acceptance scenarios follow Given-When-Then format with clear conditions
- ✅ Edge cases comprehensive (10 scenarios covering errors, permissions, formats, scale)
- ✅ Scope clearly bounded with Assumptions and Out of Scope sections
- ✅ Dependencies on Google Drive API and OAuth 2.0 explicitly stated
Feature Readiness Review
- ✅ Each functional requirement (FR-001 through FR-020) maps to acceptance scenarios in user stories
- ✅ Three user stories cover complete functionality:
- P1: Core document export (foundational value)
- P2: Sitemap generation (discovery mechanism)
- P3: Multiple formats (enhancement)
- ✅ Success criteria SC-001 through SC-010 provide clear quality gates
- ✅ Implementation details appropriately deferred (no database choices, no framework selection beyond constitution's Node.js requirement, no API route implementation specifics)
Overall Assessment
Status: ✅ PASS - Specification is complete and ready for /speckit.plan
The specification successfully:
- Defines three independently testable user stories with clear priorities
- Provides 20 concrete functional requirements
- Establishes 10 measurable success criteria
- Identifies comprehensive edge cases and assumptions
- Clearly bounds scope with explicit Out of Scope section
- Maintains technology-agnostic language while aligning with constitution's Node.js requirement
Recommendation: Proceed to planning phase with /speckit.plan command.